Project Phases

Overview diagram of project workpackages

Phase 1: Academia and Social Media

In the first phase we will analyse a combination of formal and informal communication streams and knowledge dessimination to capture the intellectual and social organisation of the communities behind various endavours to reform the sciences, as well as analyse the argumentative strategies that different actors employ in the associated discourse. Therefore, in the first phase we will conduct a social network analysis on a combination of scientmetric investigations into the academic literature and a survey with actors associated with science reforms. Simultaneously we will do a discourse analysis of the bottom-up science reform activities and their ctirics on various social media platforms and online blogs.

Phase 2: History and Policy

In the second phase we will historicise the phenomenon of reforming science and introduce the variable time in our analysis, as well as investigate how science reform idea(l)s and agendas are implemented into policy. We will first take a look at the top-down dimension of science reform by conducting a discourse analysis of the uptake of science reform idea(l)s and agendas in policy documents and then compare those with the insights gained from our analysis of the academic literature and the discourse on social media. Furthermore, we will investigate the degree to which current science reform endeavours resemble earlier episodes of reforming science, like the introduction of systematic (external) peer review and the institutionalisation of research integrity into science regulation, or demonstrate exceptionalism. An extension of the historical perspective, is also to inspect how the communities associated with science reform and their discourse evolve over time.

Phase 3: Synthesis

While we, of course, synthesise our results in the final stages of our project, the synthesis will actually be an ongoing process, fascilitated, by continuous communication and collaboration between project partners throughout the duration of the project. We will, for instance, explore whether the network structures identified in the academic literature and the survey with actors associated with science reform align with those identified on social media.

Humboldt University Berlin logo
Research Center for Science Studies logo
Aarhus University logo
CFA Lille logo
VolkswagenStiftung logo