Research Project

Reforming Science

Investigating the Reflexivity & Reflectivity of (Non)Academic Actors Advocating for Scientific Reforms

In recent years communities emerged advocating for science reforms, reacting to issues identified with, for instance, funding allocation, publishing, research(er) evaluation, reproducibility, research misconduct, and questionable research practices. Although, these "new" communities known as Open Science, Metascience, Meta-Research, or Research on Research already influence research, policy, and politics with their endeavours to change the science system, we know little about them. This project examines how actors associated with science reforms, whether supporters or critics, argue about reforms, how these communities are structured, and how current reform efforts differ from earlier fundamental changes in the working and organisation of science.

Humboldt University Berlin logo
Research Center for Science Studies logo
Aarhus University logo
CFA Lille logo
VolkswagenStiftung logo

What the Project Asks

Research Question I

Argumentation

What are the argumentative strategies and justifications of proponents and critics when discussing science reforms?

Research Question II

Structure

What are the social and intellectual structures of communities associated with science reforms, and to what extent does their knowledge production align with research specialties or scientific social movements?

Research Question III

History

How are current science reforms different from previous science reforms?

How the Research Works

Discourse

Arguments and Values

Combining analysis of bottom-up online reform discourse on Social Media with analysis of top-down policy reform discourse.

Networks

Community Structure

Network analysis using bibliometrics and survey data to trace actors, links and forms of organisation across reform communities.

Time

Historical Comparison

Exploration of science reforms and their associated communities over time, aided by a structured comparison of current science reforms with historical cases of science reform.